Prashant Raj | QuadReal’s President of Global Debt
Nov 2026 | 46 min
Prashant Raj, President of Global Debt at QuadReal Property Group, joins Nancy to make the case for balance-sheet lending, and discuss the reckoning he sees coming for borrowers.
Prashant Raj (0:00 - 0:31)
Look, discipline is really the most important virtue we can bring to the table. So, the way we look to invest is, you know, we have broad sector conviction at Quadreal in terms of things we just like. So, for us, that includes a number of different flavors of the living sector, right?
It's multifamily rentals, it's manufactured housing, purpose-built student housing, logistics, data centers, self-storage, which a number of alternatives are in there.
Nancy Lashine (0:33 - 2:59)
Hello, and thanks for tuning in to Real Estate Capital. I'm your host, Nancy Lashine of Park Madison Partners. Capital is the lifeblood of the real estate industry, but the decisions on where and how it's allocated are driven by people and personalities.
Who are they? What motivates them? What can we learn from their experiences?
On this show, we introduce you to some of the real estate industry's most influential thought leaders and decision makers, and we talk about what is important to them, how they make critical decisions, who has influenced them, and a lot more. My guest today is Prashant Raj, President of Global Debt at Quadreal Property Group. Quadreal is the global real estate investment arm of British Columbia Investment Management Corporation, one of Canada's largest public sector investors.
We had the pleasure of hosting Quadreal's CEO, Dennis Lopez, on this show last year, and we talked about their investment philosophy, the investment in technology, and the commitment to data centers and housing. There was one thread we didn't get to pull on nearly enough, and it's one of the fastest-growing parts of the business. So today, we're giving Quadreal's debt platform the focus it deserves.
Over more than 25 years, Prashant has sat in just about every seat in real estate credit. He started at the Commercial Mortgage Group at DLJ in 2000, then moved to Credit Suisse, where he spent close to a decade securitizing loans. After the crash in 2007-8, he moved to Guggenheim Partners to run commercial real estate capital markets in special situations, and then went on to lead Guggenheim Commercial Real Estate Finance.
In 2020, he joined Quadreal to lead its debt platform and has since scaled it from roughly $6 billion to more than $15 billion, extending it from its North American base into the UK and Europe. With this two-and-a-half-decade perspective, Prashant has seen the credit cycle from more angles than most, and it shows in how he thinks about what comes next. Prashant and I discussed his case for lending off your own balance sheet, his philosophy on back leverage, and how he solves for a risk premium that pays for the risk.
We cover his approach to financing data centers, Quadreal's expansion into Europe, and what he's seeing from borrowers as rates stay higher for longer. Please enjoy this conversation with Prashant. Good morning.
How are you? Good morning.
Prashant Raj (3:00 - 3:01)
I'm great. How are you?
Nancy Lashine (3:02 - 3:39)
I'm good. I'm really good. Thanks.
Beautiful, beautiful day. So, I'm excited to talk to you today, Prashant. I think you may be one of our first debt—you're certainly the first person who's been on this podcast who's sat in every seat as a debt originator in the 2007 peak, a special six investor right after the crash, and now a balance sheet lender.
So, you've really had the opportunity to see the business from multiple sides. Maybe you can just quickly take us through why you made those decisions to move from one seat to the next.
Prashant Raj (3:40 - 4:25)
Sure. When you've been around the block as long as I have, I've been at this for about 26 years, I've gotten exposure to real estate, credit, debt investments, just in a variety of different formats. I've been really fortunate to do that.
But I have to admit, none of it was by design, so there was no grand plan. I started my career at a shop called Donaldson, Lufkinen, Genred, DLJ, which some people may remember. And DLJ was a scrappy commercial mortgage conduit when I joined them in the summer of 2000.
And a small team doing a ton of business, but had very limited balance sheet. And this was back in the day where working 12, 16 hours a day, seven days a week was a badge of honor.
Nancy Lashine (4:26 - 4:28)
Not anymore? Did that change?
Prashant Raj (4:28 - 5:44)
I think things may have changed a little bit. People may think you're bananas if you're working those hours anymore. But back then, that's what it was.
And really just did a number of different things, everything from helping origination, underwriting loans, to securitizing mortgages into CMBS conduit pools, and facing off with rating agencies and BP buyers was a learning experience. DLJ got sold by its parent, OXA, to Credit Suisse vs. Boston, not that long after I got there, so at the end of 2000, which really turbocharged our business because all of a sudden we were part of a commercial bank.
The team from DLJ effectively took a lot of the senior management roles in the new real estate finance business at CSFB. And so for me, it was an incredible change where we went from a very limited balance sheet to a significant balance sheet and a much larger business. And so all of a sudden I had exposure to large loans, or what we called large loans back then, and was working on a variety of different things at CSFB.
I was there for almost 10 years through the end of 2009.
Nancy Lashine (5:45 - 5:46)
That was a fun year, wasn't it?
Prashant Raj (5:48 - 5:52)
Well, 2009 wasn't so bad. It was really 2007 and 2008 that was gut-wrenching.
Nancy Lashine (5:52 - 5:57)
You're saying by the end of 2009, everybody had capitulated?
Prashant Raj (5:58 - 6:59)
At that point, businesses were significantly smaller. Unfortunately, headcounts had shrunk. We had taken our headcount in the mortgage business at Credit Suisse down from over 400 people to a dozen people.
And so some of that had ended by 2009, and there was a focus on what's next. I happened to be part of a group of 12 professionals that were left in the business in a holding pattern, and the firm wanted us to try new things. So they actually moved us from the investment bank to the asset management side of the house to see if we could raise capital and do opportunistic things.
At that point in time, one of my long-standing clients, a shop called Guggenheim Partners, came calling saying that they were looking to get in the business and they wanted to effectively plug and play teams. And so we built a business at Guggenheim, and it was incredible.
Nancy Lashine (7:00 - 7:19)
And you were at Guggenheim until I guess 2020. We've had the privilege of having Dennis Lopez on the program as well. He's talked broadly about Quadreal's overall strategy.
Tell us why you went to Quadreal and how debt fits into the overall program.
Prashant Raj (7:20 - 8:49)
Okay, I'll talk about why I went to Quadreal. One, Dennis is an incredible salesperson and has the ability to really... He's an incredibly strategic person that can tell the story and paint a picture of a vision for 10 years.
And I didn't know that much about Quadreal when I first spoke with him. Quadreal had a prolific equity investment business when Dennis and I first spoke, but I didn't know anything about their credit business. And Dennis basically said, look, I'm looking to figure out what to do with credit.
I know it's a real opportunity. I'd love for you to tell me what do you think you'd want to do given our capital? And I can get into that in a second, but really it was just the right opportunity at the right time.
And I just happened to be very ready to embrace Quadreal at the time that the opportunity showed up. It was very long-term capital, really the opportunity to start from scratch in many ways and to build a business that could be informed by just all the scar tissue I was carrying around from all the lessons learned in banking, sales and trading, and then the different formats that we had busted at Guggenheim. So a lot of things came together.
And the chance to build a real estate debt business at Quadreal is probably one of the biggest opportunities I've had. And it's been about six years now.
Nancy Lashine (8:49 - 8:53)
Right. You've gone from $6 billion to over $15 billion today.
Prashant Raj (8:53 - 9:02)
Yeah, that's right. We're approaching $16 billion in investments and credit. And we'd like to scale that if the market opportunity persists.
Nancy Lashine (9:03 - 9:07)
And are you primarily a balance sheet lender? Is that the business today?
Prashant Raj (9:08 - 9:13)
Primarily. We eat our own cooking. We hold assets on our balance sheet.
Nancy Lashine (9:14 - 9:15)
Do you securitize them? Or not?
Prashant Raj (9:15 - 9:39)
We haven't. We're open to using securitization technology really just as more as a funding tool. So I don't think we're ever going to be classic in a grant or trust dynamic structure. We're not into the arbitrage as much.
We may use the CLO model really just as an efficient match-down financing tool.
Nancy Lashine (9:39 - 9:57)
You mentioned arbitrage, so immediately made me think. Quadreal is the pension plans of British Columbia.
And you're the investment management firm of British Columbia. It's Canadian dollar denominated is my point. How are you dealing with hedging across currencies?
Prashant Raj (9:58 - 10:54)
Sure. I mean, so everything we do, whether it's debt or equity, is hedged back to the Canadian dollars. We are investing in Canada, in the US.
The US is our biggest market, just by virtue of its size and diversity. And we're investing in Europe. And one day, when the right opportunity comes around, we'll look to invest in Asia.
But for now, it's really just North America and Europe. Everything we do in all of these jurisdictions is hedged back to CAD, Canadian dollars. There is, at this point, a rather large penalty.
The cost of hedging is fairly high, significantly higher than it has been historically. Hedging back to CAD, if you're investing in the US or in sterling, there is, in fact, a benefit to be had when you invest in euros. There still is.
So we factor the cost of hedging into all of our returns analysis. And everything has to work.
Nancy Lashine (10:54 - 11:06)
Can you give us a sense of what it costs to hedge? I mean, hedging for fixed income is always more of an issue, right? Your margins are thinner.
So what does it cost to hedge from the dollar back to CAD or from the euro back to CAD?
Prashant Raj (11:07 - 11:40)
So it depends on the hold period. And it depends on how you layer your hedges. So for us, I'd say notionally, if we had to think about things in the context of a five-year hold on an asset, and the way we hedge in the US, there's probably somewhere between a 60 and 100 basis point hit per annum for hedging.
For sterling, it's probably about 15 basis points added on to that.
Nancy Lashine (11:40 - 11:42)
So it's higher for sterling, okay.
Prashant Raj (11:42 - 11:57)
Yeah, it's higher for sterling. And it's driven by the carry differential between the risk-free rates. And for euros, there's about a 25 to 40 basis point pickup when hedging back to CAD.
Nancy Lashine (11:58 - 12:03)
How does that inform your portfolio allocation? Or does it?
Prashant Raj (12:04 - 13:15)
It does. It informs our decisions on returns. And so we're always solving for a net return where that's reflective of the risk we're taking, first and foremost.
Second, it has to be informed, it has to be accretive to the overall portfolio, because we are looking to beat certain benchmarks. And all of that has to be net of everything, right? Your costs, your hedging costs, tax, et cetera.
So it's not informing our decision to deploy capital in different jurisdictions. It just raises the clearing price to invest in certain jurisdictions. So the investments have to work, but we still like jurisdictions.
And I think Dennis probably got into it where there's rule of law where we know how, if the wheels were to come off the bus on a certain asset, where there's clarity in terms of how you could enforce on something, where you can count on your partners to do what you've agreed to do. And for us, from a credit standpoint, those jurisdictions are, it's Canada, the US, it's the UK, it's Ireland, it's the Nordics, it's Spain. And then there's a handful of jurisdictions in Asia where we'd have the same level of confidence.
Nancy Lashine (13:16 - 13:25)
You mentioned Asia now a couple of times, so I should just ask the question. I know you've been an equity investor in Asia over time. Why not debt?
Why not now?
Prashant Raj (13:26 - 13:47)
Well, we just haven't gotten around to it is the honest answer. But that's been driven by the fact that the opportunity hasn't really been a screaming one. So at this point, there's nothing that we see that we can say confidently is a really attractive credit investing opportunity in Asia where we can get scale.
And so we just haven't spent any time focusing on it.
Nancy Lashine (13:48 - 13:57)
How do you think about where you want to invest? And how do you maintain discipline at scale? Because obviously, you're lending at scale.
Prashant Raj (13:59 - 16:15)
Discipline is really the most important virtue we can bring to the table. So the way we look to invest is, we have broad sector conviction at Quadreal in terms of things we just like. So for us, that includes a number of different flavors of the living sector.
It's multi-family rentals, it's manufactured housing, purpose-built student housing, logistics, data centers, self-storage, which a number of alternatives are in there, purpose-built medical office. These are the things we really like. And so both equity and debt, we keep our focus really just on those sectors.
From a credit perspective, we like to have, on a weekly basis, a view of where we think the world is going. Very often we're wrong, but we like to have a view, even in this volatile environment. And based on that, we try and articulate very clearly what's accretive to the portfolio, what works, what do we need to add to the portfolio at any point in time, what should we be looking to sell in the portfolio, and what are the things that we really want to chase hard.
And then within that, from a debt standpoint, there's different products. It could be construction loans, it could be pre-development loans, it could be bridge loans, it could be loans on stabilized assets in floating rate format or fixed rate format. These are all things that we do.
And at any given point in time, there's always a part of the debt market where things get really commoditized. From our standpoint, we'd rather not be peddling a commodity. We'd rather be doing things that we have high conviction around, where we can clearly identify the risk, where we can get paid a very fair risk premium.
And if we can get those things to come together, then we're an investor in that product. We do have, because we have a large portfolio and a relatively small team, we're not a deployment shop. So the investment has to make sense.
We're perfectly happy to say we'll sit on our hands for a while and wait for the market to come to us, as opposed to furiously peddling and trying to get money out of the door. That's not our MO.
Nancy Lashine (16:15 - 16:33)
Sure. Are you actively, are you sitting in one investment committee and deciding whether you want to be a lender on a deal or an equity investor on a deal? Or are you opportunistic about the debt investments that you make or strategic?
Prashant Raj (16:35 - 17:30)
I'd say we're highly strategic and occasionally opportunistic. But I'd say 95%, 98% of our business is highly strategic. We have a very clear view of exactly what we want at any point in time.
There is one global investment committee, and it includes senior members of the firm. I'm on an investment committee as well. When we approach an investment committee for a transaction, it is either an equity investment specifically or a debt investment.
So we don't go look at a capital stack and say, I want the equity or I want the debt. Our teams are segregated. We share intelligence in terms of what we're experiencing in the market, what we're seeing for costs and what we're seeing for distress potentially.
But we run different processes with a firewall to keep our credit business and our equity business separated. Because often we're dealing with the same counterparties and we want to make sure we're sensitive to confidentiality and things like that.
Nancy Lashine (17:31 - 17:50)
There certainly were times over the last five years where it was obvious that every real estate investor in the market wanted to be a lender on the debt side of the equation because the returns were just better than being on the equity side. How do you think about risk-adjusted returns on the debt side?
Prashant Raj (17:54 - 18:51)
Using the corporate credit market, the ABS market, the CMBS market, we try and have a view on what is the right risk premium using something very similar to a rating agency model. What is the right risk premium for something that's in the 55 to 60 LTV or LTC range? And we do that with a dotted line to our benchmark, which is also driven by a similar hazard risk model.
It's a similar construct. And that basically informs us in the context of if you were to go further up the risk spectrums, further up the capital stack, what are the add-ons for risk? Sometimes the market doesn't give you the risk premium that is appropriate for what your model is telling you.
I mean, I'd say 80% of the time that's the case and you have to compete for business. But at the end of the day, if we think we're not getting paid a risk premium that makes sense for the risk that we think we're taking, it's not business that we're going to do.
Nancy Lashine (18:52 - 18:53)
Can you share your benchmark with us?
Prashant Raj (18:54 - 19:04)
It's published. Our benchmark is a blend of a U.S. corporate credit high yield index and a U.S. corporate credit investment rate index plus a spread.
Nancy Lashine (19:05 - 19:07)
And what does that equate to today?
Prashant Raj (19:08 - 19:39)
So the way we think about investing in credit is I'm not solving to beat the benchmark. I'm solving to beat the benchmark's yield to maturity on any given day. And because the benchmark has two components, there's a value component, there's an income component.
As you can imagine in today's world, the value component has gotten crushed. What's happened is that even though the benchmark has gotten clobbered, the yield to maturity has actually spiked because the underlying assets are effectively bonds. So I'm always looking to beat the benchmark's yield to maturity by a healthy level.
Nancy Lashine (19:41 - 19:44)
So does that make it even harder to put capital out then?
Prashant Raj (19:45 - 19:54)
Yeah, your cost of capital is even higher today. And that's a good thing because we think there's more risk in the market, right? And so I think it's appropriate.
Nancy Lashine (19:55 - 20:23)
It feels though like there's way more debt in the market today than there is equity. If I think about the last 24 hours, big deals that I've heard about, New York City office building, major retail portfolios, major industrial portfolios, they all got lots of bids on the debt. And some of them have really struggled to find the equity.
Why is that going on today in the market when clearly there's a higher risk premium?
Prashant Raj (20:25 - 21:53)
Look, it's the reason lending has been really attractive to lenders and to a bunch of equity funds over the last few years has been because of the returns. At this point in time, there's even more incentive for debt capital to flow into the marketplace because base rates are higher and you can actually get very attractive yields. Those really attractive yields are making it really hard for equity investors to actually have deals pencil.
And for that reason, there just isn't that much. It's really hard to get LPs to sign up on a deal. There's a lot of GPs running around trying to put LPs together, but it's really hard.
And lenders are trying to get more business done and are not looking to drop yields right now. What I think is going to happen is transaction activity is going to slow down. Our view is when we feel that values are more durable, which means valuations have reset, which could happen this year and probably into next year, and we feel that there's more upside in property valuations than downside, our goal will be to then step in and fill some of that gap between a traditional lender and where equity is stalling out.
And that can be done in BNOTE, MESNOTE, or even preferred equity formats. And we're seeing some of those opportunities today.
Nancy Lashine (21:56 - 22:11)
Maybe it was a year ago- the CMBS market's been very strong, certainly picked up. Are you a buyer of, when you talk about BNOTES, you're a buyer of issuances there, or are you more looking to actually be an originator of CMBS eventually?
Prashant Raj (22:12 - 23:20)
We are not going to be an originator of CMBS. We're not a flow buyer of CMBS. We're not buying that new issue, certainly.
We view the CMBS market as a place where we would play on an opportunistic basis. So at any given point in time, we have a view on a handful of Q-sips that we've already underwritten, primarily in the SASB space, but now increasingly even in the conduit space, where we know we like the risk. And we have a price that we want to get paid.
It's not the price that you can get at new issue. We in fact went to our investment committee earlier this year when the bond market was getting a little skittish and said, look, here's a bunch of deals we like, here are the specific Q-sips we like, and here's a yield threshold that we like at a certain dollar price. And we got approval.
The market has finally gotten to a point where those bonds are now available at the price we would want to buy them. So we're buying bonds right now. We're completely opportunistic.
We'll buy CMBS on risk we like, when the price is at the right level, but not on a flow.
Nancy Lashine (23:21 - 23:30)
How do risk premiums vary between lending in North America versus in Europe today, and maybe UK as a separate aspect element?
Prashant Raj (23:31 - 24:46)
It's driven primarily by market participants. So the banks have historically been pretty active in Europe. Insurance companies have been active in Europe.
Just over the last four years, a number of debt funds, very private equity style, real estate credit capital has shown up in Europe. There's an alt lender boom that happened over the last four years in Europe that we experienced the same thing in the States. In terms of risk premiums, I feel like the market, like the UK market has seen lending spreads collapse dramatically over the last 18 months.
That may change in the near term, because I think there's more and more people just concerned about macro risk in the UK. We're seeing spreads finally beginning to widen here in the States after just grinding in over the last two and a half years. And in Europe, there's still a lot of bank capital.
There's still some insurance company capital that's very active. But the UK has got significant macroeconomic headwinds right now. And a lot that needs to get figured out.
So I'd say most foreign lenders looking to invest in Europe are probably just waiting and watching.
Nancy Lashine (24:48 - 25:09)
Has the private equity business, private equity firms buying insurance companies, or sometimes vice versa, changed the lending landscape from your perspective? I mean, it started obviously with Apollo and Athene, but I don't think there's a major private equity firm today that hasn't affiliated itself with an insurance balance sheet.
Prashant Raj (25:10 - 25:53)
It has, because all of a sudden, private equity capital that was typically chasing high single-digit, low double-digit return bogeys are using insurance capital, which is also longer-dated capital, because most of these insurance accounts, whether it's KKR's outfit, Global Atlantic, or Athene and others, it's mostly life in annuity capital. With those insurance accounts, it's longer-dated stuff. And the cost of capital is quite attractive and really quite suitable for real estate finance.
And mortgages are a very attractive asset class for insurance regulators. It's been another source of competition.
Nancy Lashine (25:54 - 26:04)
Does it ever make you wonder, maybe as you're leaving the office and going home from work, about the stability of the insurance market when you see what's going on?
Prashant Raj (26:06 - 26:12)
I have to be completely candid. I haven't spent one minute worrying about the stability of the insurance market. I do worry about it.
Nancy Lashine (26:12 - 26:14)
Okay, I'm all alone with that worry. There you go.
Prashant Raj (26:15 - 26:20)
I do worry about the competition that comes from those sources of capital.
Nancy Lashine (26:20 - 26:29)
Sure. And a lot of folks back-leverage their loans to get higher returns. What's your philosophy about that?
Prashant Raj (26:30 - 27:40)
Look, the product that I'm responsible for is debt. So I'm not averse to leverage. But as an investor, how much leverage you apply to your portfolio is something that we should spend some time thinking about.
Leverage can turbocharge returns and make a lot of things work. But it can really constrain you when things get hard. Everyone's got different capital, but I think it's really important that investors look at their portfolios and determine how much leverage and what type of leverage is suitable for their portfolios.
We are not lending based on back leverage. So it's not a prerequisite for us. We would not make a loan that only worked because of the back leverage.
Then you find yourself levering yourself up to the guilds. And that really takes away any operating flexibility you have when things get hard. So that's not our ML.
We run fairly low leverage levels in our portfolio. It's in the teens. We can go higher.
I think if we double that or even triple that, it'd be just fine. But it's not a driver of business for us.
Nancy Lashine (27:41 - 27:52)
Fair enough. Is there a common theme amongst the sectors that you are lending on today? Is there a common denominator that you can share?
Prashant Raj (27:52 - 29:06)
It's very specific. There's two things.
The first is the sectors that we invest in just have to have very clear long-term demand drivers. There'll be points in time where a sector like logistics or residential rentals will get overbuilt and will get oversupplied. But we want really long-term demand drivers.
And so the things that I articulated earlier, the things that we care about are all driven by that we know that there are long-term demand drivers. So that's really important. And then we also focus on sectors where there's really low capex because capex can erode returns significantly over time.
So we don't really focus on things like office buildings and hotels. And that's driven by our thesis around capex. That capex thesis is less relevant for credit.
So from a credit standpoint, we'd be more open to doing things like financing hotels and office buildings because when capex surprises you, it's really the equity investor's problem, not the credit, not the lender's problem.
Nancy Lashine (29:06 - 29:08)
Most of the time, right?
Prashant Raj (29:08 - 29:08)
Yeah.
Nancy Lashine (29:08 - 29:12)
How do you get comfortable lending on data centers? Walk us through that thesis.
Prashant Raj (29:13 - 30:49)
Sure. We think that there's for the foreseeable future, there's significant demand for compute. It's driven by just the amount of data that all of us, whether it's individuals or enterprises, are just creating.
So even before the boom that we're experiencing from AI, there's just been a massive demand for data storage and compute. Quadreal got in the game pretty early around 2017, 2018. And the scale of the demand has just been exponential, right?
There used to be a time where a 5 or 10 megawatt data center was the norm. Now everything is 300, 600 or more megawatts or more in demand. From a lending standpoint, we really like financing the development of data centers.
We have a very specific thesis. We will not take entitlement risk. We will not take risk on the delivery of power.
And we want a credit-worthy investment-grade hyperscaler lease on the back end. So from our standpoint, we're happy to go really far up the stack and finance the development of a data center because we know there's an Alphabet or an AWS or a Microsoft, someone else, that's going to lease the space when it's delivered. And even if the market gets oversupplied, just the income from that long-term lease will pay us current and amortize the loan to zero.
Nancy Lashine (30:50 - 30:56)
So is that the criteria? The lease has to take the loan to full amortization?
Prashant Raj (30:56 - 31:02)
Yeah, given the fact that it's usually a 12 or 15-year lease, right now it works pretty well.
Nancy Lashine (31:03 - 31:09)
And what's the yield premium that you would get over buying an Amazon bond, let's say?
Prashant Raj (31:10 - 32:13)
So finally, the spreads for financing data centers are beginning to become more meaningful. So for a long time, the banks, primarily project finance and infra-balance sheets within banks, have stepped in pretty forcefully and driven spreads on the financing of data center development down to levels where it was unattractive to us. We could go finance a very bite-sized multi-family development in a market we really liked and get paid a whole lot more in spread, often double or triple what was available in data centers.
Finally, I think the market's beginning to think about how much exposure they've got to data centers in a whole variety of formats, whether it's corporate credit or ABS or CMBS or other formats, and spreads are beginning to move in our direction where it's becoming meaningful. So from a lending perspective, we've done very little data center financing because the risk premium was not attractive, but we're beginning to see opportunities that make a lot of sense now.
Nancy Lashine (32:14 - 32:26)
Do you attribute that just to saturation, the total dollar volume relative to the available capital, or to what's going on broadly with the concerns about AI being a bubble or something else?
Prashant Raj (32:26 - 33:34)
I think it's all of that. I think before people began to worry about is AI a bubble, I think it was just saturation. The sources of capital went from, we can't get enough of this stuff and we want an allocation to an issuance, or we have to have an allocation to this issuance, to, hey, there's just more and more paper every week, and let's be really thoughtful about what we're signing up for.
Because we know that if we miss out on this one, there'll be something to look at next week. And it's coming in all kinds of formats. I think banks, especially, but a number of other lenders are being a little bit more deliberate about what they're taking down.
And that's causing a little bit of a backup in the market, which is causing spreads to back up a little bit. And I think there's, I'd say all of this year, we've seen lenders beginning to distinguish between the really good credits and the slightly guspy credits. And you're seeing that in the CDS market right now.
Nancy Lashine (33:34 - 34:02)
Right. We spend most of our day at Park Madison talking to equity owners and investors who tend to see the glass, even if it's half full, filling up. And I'm just reminded in talking with you that as a lender, it's maybe the other direction, glass is half full, but you're always looking at the risk.
What's the downside protection? So what are you seeing today from your seat that the headline numbers aren't showing?
Prashant Raj (34:03 - 34:35)
I do want to address the whole glass half full nature. So people do tend to think of the equity investors tend to be more optimistic and lenders tend to be more pessimistic. And the way I think about it is being a lender gives you a really good sense of identifying risk.
I don't think it makes you risk averse, but I think it helps you identify risk and it teaches you to demand a premium, a risk premium, because you don't have all the upside that the equity guys would have.
Nancy Lashine (34:35 - 34:36)
Right.
Prashant Raj (34:36 - 36:07)
So I think it makes credit guys just better at focusing on the risks. But I think it also makes us better at taking risk, even though we may not be optimists. The thing that's going on in the marketplace today that we've been spending time thinking about and running some analysis on our portfolio is a number of borrowers, whether it's industrial, multifamily rentals, storage, are experiencing some sort of shell shock right now because they've spent the past 24 months assuming that rates were going to go down, cap rates were going to compress.
And being the optimist that they tend to be, they saw light at the end of the tunnel. And that's been snuffed out a little bit at this point. Rates have gone the wrong way.
We're talking about cap rate expansion. And so we worry about what's going to happen to sponsors who have to get out of an asset, who need to do something. And so we think there's going to be people that are just going to have to recap these stacks in the near term because they can't keep doing this.
They've been doing it, they've been paying a higher cost of funds for a long time. And unless the market turns dramatically where there's some sort of bubble that pops that causes a recession and rates to go down, I think there's going to be a lot of recaps near term, which means there's going to be some pain to be taken on the equity side.
Nancy Lashine (36:08 - 36:47)
I don't think that's news though to the market. I think everybody sees that at this point. There's still people holding out because they don't have to do anything yet.
There's a general sense of despair. And if you walk into a room full of, say, multi-family owners, it's deathly. People are so depressed because they've lost so much value because of interest rates and cap rates that are going to have to go up.
You don't see it as much in the other asset classes like industrial or the niche categories where cap rates were in the 6%, 7%, even 8% so that they can still finance on a positive basis.
Prashant Raj (36:48 - 37:04)
You're right. And I feel like people have been waiting for just things to get better. And if we stay where we are, I'm assuming rates don't go higher, I think there's going to have to be some capitulation in 2027.
Nancy Lashine (37:06 - 37:28)
Well, I think we're all hoping for it because as you say, that'll allow transaction volume to pick up and also performance to improve for investors who are putting fresh capital to work and that will feed a positive cycle. Let me ask you, as we're getting towards the end here, you've lived through two major downdrafts. What mistakes are you determined not to repeat?
Prashant Raj (37:29 - 39:27)
Sure. I have experienced two major downdrafts, a number of mini downturns, and I've learned a lot of lessons and I carry the scars on my back. In terms of business, what I've learned is it's really important to have a good sense of what your capital really needs and then to design what you do to make sure it's completely appropriate for the capital you're deploying, as opposed to being all things to all people and trying to compete with every other market participant.
If you don't maintain discipline, you can end up with a whole bunch of misfit toys in terms of assets, as opposed to a portfolio that's curated specifically for your capital. We have very specific capital, it's pension plan capital. We're lending to help pensioners, teachers, firefighters, hydro workers meet their pension requirements.
We're very cognizant of that. What I've learned is to not just build scale for the sake of scale. We all want to be more and more relevant in our organizations, and sometimes size is a factor that drives relevance within an organization.
Quadreal, thankfully, is not that place. It's a place where there's a real incentive to do the right thing the right way. I've been able to pull that off.
The second thing is I've realized that professionally, I derive most of my satisfaction from work based on the people that I surround myself with. The work's important, the quality of work and all the things that go with that are important, but it's really the people that you surround yourself with that make it fun to wake up in the morning and come into an office. I've had the benefit of having incredible mentors and bosses over the years, and I'm trying to do the same thing here for the team that we have.
Keeping that piece of the puzzle working is super important.
Nancy Lashine (39:28 - 39:30)
What are you looking for in the people that you're hiring?
Prashant Raj (39:31 - 40:31)
We have a very specific culture here at Quadreal where everyone's incentivized to work hard and be smart and do the right thing. That's probably the case everywhere. But for us, there's a real emphasis on collaborating with each other.
You are expected to pick up the phone and call a colleague back if they've called you asking for help. It's really important to do that. We don't operate as silos.
It's a very team-based focus, so we don't have rainmakers, prima donnas, heroes running around.
That means that people can build long-term careers here. If they want to be in real estate, they can do pretty much anything in real estate at Quadreal because we do everything. We're looking for good, smart people who can be team players.
Nancy Lashine (40:31 - 40:38)
Has the growth in AI changed how you interview people or skill sets that you might be looking specifically for?
Prashant Raj (40:39 - 41:04)
Yeah, definitely. We're looking for people who are up to speed in terms of using what's available with AI models. For work, people who can build models with AI.
The team that we have in place is fully up to speed. As we add people, it's going to have to be people that can take advantage of the technology that's available. That's a big focus here.
Nancy Lashine (41:06 - 41:53)
Well, in closing, I have to ask you a question that I've been thinking about. You grew up in Delhi, came here for grad school. You've been here a long time.
I've never been to India, but I'm having the privilege of going next year for the first time flying to Delhi. I grew up here in Manhattan. I was raised from birth here.
You're raising three kids here in New York. What crosses your mind sometimes when you're on your way home or sitting at dinner with your kids thinking how different their life is here than what you grew up with? How does that sense of perspective inform who you are and how you operate?
Just a small question, I know. Sorry.
Prashant Raj (41:54 - 43:14)
My wife and I, we often talk about how fortunate our kids are growing up in New York City. It's an incredibly diverse place, fast paced.
They're exposed to so much here, which we hope will stand them in good stead as they go about their lives. New York is about as close as you can get to a city in India in terms of the way it feels. I travel back to India often.
My parents live in Delhi. Delhi is hustle and bustle, and it's a different level of density than New York City, but there's a lot of similarities. There's chaos, lots of people on the sidewalk, everyone's heading somewhere, there's traffic congestion.
It feels very similar. There's other cities in the world that are also very similar. I think Hong Kong, London feels that way too.
I think it's a real privilege. You're incredibly fortunate to have lived in New York your whole life. I'm hoping that'll be true for my kids as well.
The city has become really livable over the last 20 years or so, and we really didn't feel pressure to grab our kids and move to the suburbs. We think that was the right decision for them, and hopefully it'll pan out. But when you are planning a trip to India, I'd love to help you.
Nancy Lashine (43:14 - 43:17)
Oh, sold!
Prashant Raj (43:18 - 43:22)
It's an incredible place to visit, incredible people. I think you'd have a blast.
Nancy Lashine (43:23 - 43:47)
Well, maybe we'll have to do a recap after India. And it's interesting, we've looked at a lot of real estate opportunities in India. Personally, early in Park Madison's career, invested in some of them just to learn the market.
Fortunately, never sold any to institutional investors, because it was kind of a small window in time where that made a lot of sense.
Prashant Raj (43:50 - 44:26)
The real estate markets in India are booming. I think it's hard to be a foreign investor in India. It's super important.
Partner selection is super important. And you really got to worry about government regulations, some of which will pop up along the way. And you got to really worry about currency hedging, which can take meaningful chunks out of your return.
I've never actually worked professionally in India. So I've only ever worked in the US. And so for someone that spent their time in North America or Europe, and able to go be a professional in India, I think there's a lot to consider and think about.
Nancy Lashine (44:27 - 44:48)
Well, this may not be your last chapter. We'll see.
Thank you so much for joining us today. Really appreciate your comments and great insights into what's going on in the debt markets and from an incredible firm with just a great success story at Quadreal. So thanks for joining us.
Prashant Raj (44:48 - 44:50)
Thanks for the opportunity. It was lovely meeting you.
Nancy Lashine (44:51 - 45:27)
Likewise. I hope you enjoyed this episode of Real Estate Capital. Before you go, I have a quick favor to ask.
We put a lot of thought and effort into this show and making sure we bring you insights from real estate leaders that you don't normally find in the mainstream media. So if you're enjoying the show, please remember to follow it on your favorite podcasting app so you never miss an episode. We'd also love for you to share it with others or give us a review on Apple podcasts so others can find us.
Thanks again for tuning in. For more information about our firm, please visit our website at park Madison partners.com